Search Loci: Convergence:
I remember one occasion when I tried to add a little seasoning to a review, but I wasn't allowed to. The paper was by Dorothy Maharam, and it was a perfectly sound contribution to abstract measure theory. The domains of the underlying measures were not sets but elements of more general Boolean algebras, and their range consisted not of positive numbers but of certain abstract equivalence classes. My proposed first sentence was: "The author discusses valueless measures in pointless spaces."
I Want to Be a Mathematician, Washington: MAA Spectrum, 1985, p. 120.
The Magic Squares of Manuel Moschopoulos
1. Rhabdas means staff or stick. Its meaning here is unknown. Sir Thomas Heath  seems to regard it as a man's name. Conceivably it could mean son of Rhabdas, a common use of to [(u)] + genitive
2. An evenly-even number is a positive integer of the form 2n, for some positive integer n.
3. Literally 'the monad', Greek monaV . Early Greek arithmetical theory regarded the number 1, the monad, as a special object, from which all numbers emanated, rather than as a number in its own right. I have translated the term as 'the number one' throughout. See  , Vol.1, pp.69f.
4. An evenly-odd number is generally taken to refer to a number of the form 2(2m+1). See  , Vol. 1, p.72. Moschopoulos may, however, be refering to those numbers traditionally called oddly-even, which have the form 2n(2m+1), for n,m ³1.
5. Literally, an 'equal sided quadrangle'. Moschopoulos abbreviates this to 'quadrangle' in what follows. I translate this as 'square' or 'number square'. Square integers are still thought of geometrically, and the 'side' of a square refers, of course, to the square root. This leads to some confusion in the Greek which I have attempted to overcome in translation.
8. Moschopoulos here uses the term 'side', pleura, to refer to the sum of the numbers on any 'side' (i.e. row or column). He often confuses this use of the word 'side' with the 'side length' of the square. Thus the 'side' of a three-by-three magic square is 15, but the 'side of the square' is 3. To avoid this confusion I have used the term Side for the sum of the numbers along any side and 'side' for the side length.
11. Literally, 'the amount corresponding to each monad of the sides'.
12. Literally, 'it occurs by necessity.' Moschopoulos is, of course, using the fact that åi=1n i = 1/2n2 + 1/2n. Nowhere in his writings does he attempt to prove any of his claims. This result was well known in antiquity, since for each positive integer n this formula gives the triangular numbers. See  , Vol II, p.499.
20. It is not clear why M. chose this archetype rather than the one constructed using the earlier method. It has been suggested that M. is simply copying some earlier material of which he has little understanding.