Search Loci: Convergence:
I have resumed the study of mathematics with great avidity. It was ever my favourite one ... where no uncertainties remain on the mind; all is demonstration and satisfaction.
James J. Tattersall, Elementary Number Theory in Nine Chapters, Cambridge University Press, 2005
Page 1 of 1
Review of The Genesis of Science: The Story of Greek Imagination
The Genesis of Science: The Story of Greek Imagination, by Stephen Bertman, 2010, 293 pp., Illustrations, $27, hardcover, ISBN 13: 978-1-61614-217-9. Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books. www.prometheusbooks.com/
Given that the book is written for a wide audience, the author makes significant use of literature and mythology to argue his points. For example, in the discussion on optics, Bertman uses a quote from Homer’s Iliad to illustrate a fundamental trait of the ancient Greeks – the urge to see – and argues that "[i]t was this abiding trait that, centuries later, made science possible, and made the ancient Greeks its true inventors" (p. 49). Undoubtedly, Bertman is a passionate admirer of the ancient Greeks and he focuses his narrative on mostly positive aspects of Greek history. For example, whereas other authors (such as David Lindberg in The Beginnings of Western Science (1992)) have admitted that the evidence of Greek medicine is spotty and were unsatisfied with having to rely solely on literary sources for evidentiary support, in his discussion on Greek medicine Bertman makes no such statements.
If you are a mathematics educator or mathematics historian looking for a Greek history of mathematics text, I can assure you the mathematical content of this book is limited. There is no chapter titled "Mathematics" – only a chapter on "the language on the universe" (p. 43). Spanning about three and a half pages, the narrative includes a general discussion of Greek fascination with the abstract nature of numbers and shapes and their deductive approach to mathematics.
Lindberg, D. C. (1992). The beginnings of western science. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Kuleshova, Angelina, "Review of The Genesis of Science: The Story of Greek Imagination," Loci (May 2011), DOI: 10.4169/loci003673