Search MAA Reviews:
Practical Biostatistics: A User-Friendly Approach for Evidence-Based Medicine
Mendel Suchmacher and Mauro Geller
Publisher: Academic Press (2012)
Details: 236 pages, Paperback
MAA Review[Reviewed by Russell Jay Hendel, on 12/31/2012]
Practical Biostatistics is a clearly written and well laid out textbook. I would recommend its use for either an introductory biostatistics course or a graduate course targeted to students specializing in health-care. This book could also be used in a standard first year undergraduate introductory statistics course if the instructor doesn’t mind overemphasizing clinical applications. If the book is used as a standalone text the instructor may find it helpful to supplement the exercises; but these days there are many available data sets available online.
The book has the following useful features:
Lean and lively look: A comprehensive statistics book with only 236 pages! The text has 46 sections which neatly adapt to a traditional fifteen week course meeting three days a week. About 25% of these sections are “appendices” showing how to implement important statistical tests in Excel. Thus this book could equally serve as a text for an introductory bio-statistics course with a one-day a week lab component.
Software friendly: The book is written assuming Excel as an accompanying software package. The chief virtue of this is that Excel is almost universally available as part of the Microsoft Office suite. All software algorithms are completely explained in the text (this will be detailed below).
Before continuing with the book’s other useful features we should compare Excel with Minitab and SAS two other popular statistical software packages.
Returning to our enumeration of virtues of this book:
Completely detailed and diagrammed algorithms: The text explains every important algorithm and subalgorithm with detailed steps, each step typically being accompanied by a data table and excel snapshot.
The following example is illustrative: determination whether a data distribution is normal or not: Such a determination is an important prior step in implementing certain statistical tests (such as linear regression). Many books only mention this requirement but then do not indicate how to assess normality. Certain texts may even mention tests, such as the Anderson-Darling test, with only a mention of what p-values indicate normality without any intuitive explanation of the test. Other texts may simply mention that you graph the standardized scores and see if they look normal without any further criteria on what looking normal means.
Practical Biostatistics devotes a whole step, step 5 of the investigator hypothesis examination, to test for normality. Step 5 occupies an entire chapter, chapter 8, of the book. Here is how the book approaches this important test.
First: The algorithm of converting data to a curve of standardized scores is presented.
Second: The authors illustrate this method with a detailed data example. Three tables are presented in their entirety — (i) original data, (ii) standardized data, (iii) frequency table of standardized data.
Third: The authors give four criteria (which this reviewer has never seen in a textbook) for assessment of whether the resulting curve is normal: (i) are mean, median and mode close, (ii) is the curve symmetric without skewness or kurtosis (iii) does 95% of the curve lie within two standard deviations of the mean and (iv) is the coefficient of variation between 25% and 50%?
Fourth: The authors then walk the student through going from a data table to a normal curve in Microsoft Excel. Their explanation uses nine Excel snapshots.
Such an attention to detail is important in an introductory statistics course where the students are typically not math majors and need such walkthroughs.
Knowledgeable authors: Both authors are professors of immunology and work as consultants for the pharmaceutical industry in the clinical research field.
Detailed discussion of applications: How refreshing to see Parts I and II of the book — (2 1/2 weeks of lectures) — devoted to a detailed discussion of data studies. Instead of diving right into the math or have a small introductory section discussing the difference between categorical and interval variables, the authors carefully discuss the various types of clinical studies: ecological, cross-sectional, longitudinal, observational, intervention, case-control, cohort, stratified etc. Such discussions make the subject appear real. Such discussions are especially useful for beginning graduate students in the health care field.
User friendly summaries, diagrams and tables: The book is copyrighted 2012 and indeed has the flavor of a post-2010 book. The text is replete with summaries, diagrams and tables. For example the first 11 pages discussing the types of epidemiological studies, has 4 diagrams and an entire section summarizing the various types and subtypes of epidemiological studies. Such user friendly aids are especially useful to undergraduates who may not yet know how to study technical material.
Suggested Readings: It is common these days for books to have bibliographic references to other very useful books and articles. Practical Biostatistics gives URLs of websites with clinical research articles, such as medline, as well as other useful journal articles. For example, I was delighted to find a four-part article series in the CMAJ, Canadian Medical Association Journal, titled “Basic Statistics for Clinicians,” which reviews illustrations of basic statistics needed by clinicians.
Problems: A nice feature of the book is that it presents annotated solutions to all problems (not just the odd number problems).
My only criticism of the book is the lack of sufficient problems. But that is not insurmountable in this day and age, when data sets on a variety of topics are freely available on the web. An instructor can use them for homework, tests and classroom illustration. My favorite compendium of such free data sets is provided by the course home pages of the AP (Advanced Placement) section of the College Board website, accessible at http://apcentral.collegeboard.com/apc/members/courses/teachers_corner/22027.html.
If I had to chose between a text (i) with many homework exercises but a lack of illustrative algorithmic diagrams and a lack of in-depth discussion on types of statistical studies vs. (ii) a text with many illustrative algorithmic diagrams and in-depth discussion on types of statistical studies I would certainly chose (ii) over (i). I would be choosing between providing extra homework problems or providing illustrations of extra steps and it is certainly easier to provide extra homework problems.
Russell Jay Hendel (RHendel@Towson.Edu) holds a Ph.D. in theoretical mathematics and an Associateship from the Society of Actuaries. He teaches at Towson University. His interests include discrete number theory, applications of technology to education, problem writing, actuarial science and the interaction between mathematics, art and poetry.